Why New Medical Evidence Matters in a Disability Appeal

During the appeals process, the Social Security Administration (SSA) gives you the opportunity to submit updated or additional evidence. Here’s why it’s important:

Strengthening Your Case
If your initial application lacked enough proof, new medical documents can fill in the gaps and address the reasons for denial.

Showing Worsening Conditions

Your health may have declined since your original application. Updated records can show the SSA that your condition has gotten worse, making your case even stronger.

Demonstrating Consistent Medical Care
Ongoing treatment records show that you’re actively seeking care for your condition, which can improve your credibility with decision-makers.

Responding to SSA’s Specific Concerns
Often, the denial letter will mention missing or insufficient information. New evidence can directly answer those concerns.

What Types of New Evidence Should You Submit?

Here’s the kind of updated information that can make a big impact during your appeal:

• Recent medical records, lab results, and imaging (MRI, CT scans, etc.)
• New diagnoses from specialists
• Updated treatment plans or changes in prescribed medications
• Detailed letters from treating physicians describing your limitations
• Mental health evaluations if mental conditions are involved
• Hospitalization records or surgery reports
• Functional capacity evaluations (physical or mental)

The more comprehensive and current your evidence is, the better your chances of winning the appeal.

When Can You Submit New Medical Evidence?

You can submit new evidence at almost every stage of the appeals process, including:

• Reconsideration (the first level of appeal)
• Hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)
• Appeals Council Review



However, it’s crucial to submit your evidence as early as possible to give it full consideration during your review.